Mama Marie`s Italian Market in Pitman

Mama Marie`s Italian Market in Pitman
5 / 5
50 reviews

29 S Broadway, Pitman, NJ 08071-1413, Pitman

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Italian
Features
  • Takeout
  • Reservations
  • Seating
Good for
  • Kids
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

7:00 am

Wednesday

7:00 am

Friday

7:00 am

Sunday

7:00 am

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Mama Marie`s Italian Market
BL
B L
google
04.20.2024
5/5

Yo this place has the best breakfast sandwiches in the area. Great service and nice people!!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JP
Jason Pogue
google
09.01.2018
5/5

Amazing everything!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
DD
Debra DiPatri
google
08.03.2018
5/5

I love this place so much. They have the best food and sandwiches. The service is wonderful and it's like being with family. Never had a bad experience here.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
HH
Holly H.
google
06.17.2018
5/5

So good!! Had a hot Pastrami on Panini bread with provolone and sauerkraut. Best I've ever had!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
CB
Ciara Bates
google
06.16.2018
1/5

I visited Mama Maria’s with my grandmother, mother and aunt for lunch. I purchased a soda while my family ate lunch. I was not feeling well so did not order anything to eat. I had a BITE of my mother’s sandwich and she was charged a $2.00 “sharing fee” at the register. We were never warned and furthermore have never heard of such a fee being imposed at a small establishment during lunchtime. CHEAP, CLASSLESS AND RUDE. I like supporting small businesses but will no longer support this one.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
GM
Gilbert Marquez
google
05.19.2018
5/5

In the past 12 hours I've had their meatballs with ziti for dinner and their breakfast sandwich with pork roll. The best. If you're social-distancing, their to-go food is perfect.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
IG
Ivelisse Gonzalez
google
05.03.2018
5/5

The staff was nice and accommodating, we had two small children who were fussy, and still were treated nicely. Thank you the food was Great!!!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
ZH
Zachary Harmon
google
03.21.2018
5/5

Great food, great price. Big portions and love from a family owned business

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
CM
Connor Mitchell
google
03.02.2018
5/5

Easily one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in a long time. The Old World Italian was excellent along with the Estevio. On top of the great lunch, I received four of their 12” rolls. Without a doubt, I’ll be going back for more.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JM
Jeff Mazzola
google
10.09.2017
5/5

Best subs in the area. Very reasonable catering services.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
WA
Wayne Ashton
google
10.04.2017
4/5

Absolutely great breakfast sandwiches and the best meatballs around

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JD
James DC
google
10.03.2017
5/5

Awesome sandwiches

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
mf
michael frick
google
09.21.2017
5/5

Good sandwiches, excellent lunch meat selection and a new breakfast menu 👍

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
HH
Haylie Hennigan
google
08.15.2017
5/5

This place has the best meatballs around!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
KS
Kyle Sheppard
google
06.22.2017
5/5

Delicious sandwiches. Many to choose from, everything is great

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
ph
please help save bay wetlands fish and wildlife
google
06.15.2017
1/5

Called on the phone yesterday afternoon to ask about the food and they with a less than friendly attitude told me to go online, and answered other questions in a bitter tone. Doesn't make me want to rush to go and buy a sandwich or have lunch or dinner in that kind of environment. I know a lot of people put up with chitty service for a good sub hoagie but eventually it will catch up to this restaurant too. Unwelcoming and ungrateful demeanor and made us feel stupid for asking a couple questions. We are local and could have given lots of repeat business over years, just recently became interested in a good hoagie. Will be looking for other places, unless we get contacted by the owner to resolve.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
MT
Matthew Toy
google
06.11.2017
5/5

Probably your only oasis in the desert that is South Jersey's hoagie shops. These are made with high quality meats and top notch bread. I have yet to find its equal out side of South Philly.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
SB
S Bastow
google
06.11.2017
5/5

Food good and prices reasonable! Best around!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
Erik
google
06.09.2017
4/5

When you're one of the few stores open on Monday apparently, their sandwiches are fantastic and the hospitality is like walking into your own Italian family.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
FP
Frank Pino
google
04.26.2017
5/5

One of my favorite places to go for Italian sandwiches! Delicious food and inexpensive too!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
DB
Dave Brooks
google
04.18.2017
5/5

All of the things I have had at Mama Marie's have been great! Owner and staff are awesome as well!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
gg
greg gras
google
04.17.2017
5/5

I just ordered breakfast and was blown away! Everything was cooked to perfection, I have 20 yrs. experience cooking and first thing you learn is if you can cook an egg, you can cook anything. I can't wait to do their sandwiches, good damn, that was good! My wife is Sicilian and is probably the only one who can't cook! I'ma send her to you guys for a couple of days!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
QD
QuyAsia DuBose
google
03.22.2017
5/5

Best Italian spot to eat at in Pitman. Great service and very respectful. Love their breakfast sandwiches.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
ML
Michael Lindner
google
03.16.2017
5/5

Best variety of hoagies in the area, try dante's inferno if you are man enough.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
BW
Brian Watkins
google
02.25.2017
2/5

Not bad, but one of the staff was going hard about how they're the best in the state. Not city or town, state. This was foolish to do before I got my food, because the hype was a let down. I was told you can't actually order cheesesteaks and that I was lucky to be getting one. I mean they are a hoagie shop, but still that was a bit surprising. I wanted to be like "well you're lucky to have a customer" since the place was empty at lunch time. Also the drinks are expensive and the cheesesteak was really not that good at all. I didn't feel lucky. Still I've had worse and their hoagies are world class. Stick with what you know.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JC
Jennie Cusick
google
02.19.2017
5/5

Great sandwich. I had a delicious pannini with smoked mozzerrella, grilled chicken, spinach and aioli with roasted peppers. The service was great and the meal prep was quick and served hot.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
PH
Pam Harrison
google
01.24.2017
5/5

I have dined in Mama Marie’s countless times and am never disappointed. My sandwich was delectable. Will definitely be returning! I had the “Pat” sandwich.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
ES
Enrico Sepulveda
google
01.06.2017
4/5

Deli style Not sure if staff is used to serving customers at the tables.Was very uncomfortable having breakfast here. Had to ask for everything extra effort to serve us.Food was cold, girl took a break on us and left store. Our order was sitting on the counter for 5 minutes already finished. Guess it was waiting for us to serve ourselves.Sad.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
cw
chris wood
google
11.27.2016
5/5

Fantastic Paninis! Quality ingredients. As soon as you open the door, and the smell of meats and cheeses hits your nose. If you like chicken, get a Godfather, if eggplant is what you crave, ask for the Sinatra. If you're in town shopping or driving near Pitman, you need to stop here and taste real food!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
LL
Lindsay L Hutchinson
google
11.10.2016
5/5

Best chicken parm sandwich of my entire life.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
VD
Victoria DCI Talent Stadium 04Aug T
google
08.25.2016
5/5

Excellent....will be back

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
AG
Aidan Grigus
google
08.20.2016
5/5

If you don't mind waiting for a couple of minutes, I'd full heartedly suggest Mama Marie's. It is the best sandwich shop I've been to yet, and has an amazing atmosphere with their other foods (those that I've tried, obviously) being amazing. Five stars for sure.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
KM
Kristy Martin-Siewert
google
08.16.2016
5/5

Delicious and quality products! They Now DELIVER!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
AM
Amanda Munyon
google
08.01.2016
3/5

Food here is amazing! I’ve gone back more than 5 times but won’t be anymore because of the service. The guy that answers the phone/cashes you out at the register is rude and makes it seem like customers are an inconvenience.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
CM
Colin Murray
google
07.20.2016
5/5

Amazing sandwiches, very generous portion, more than worth the price!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
RM
Ryland McGinley
google
07.16.2016
5/5

Always good

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
Sarah
google
07.08.2016
2/5

If it was not for the fact that they have delicious hoagies, I would give them 0 stars. Last time I was here, they gave us meatless hoagies!! I have never had an experience like that!! The woman didn't even care about us and was being rude and on her phone the whole time when we were trying to order. Sometimes there is a long wait so you better take a seat. The hoagies (when made with meat) are huge but delicious!!!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
VL
Vw Luvin
google
06.25.2016
5/5

Amazing local deli, party platters, breakfast sandwiches and hogies are all great!!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
cg
cassie griffith
google
06.20.2016
4/5

GIVING 4 STARS BECAUSE, THE 4 STARS ARE FOR THE FOOD. FOOD WAS EXCELLENT... DIDNT GIVE THE 5TH STAR BECAUSE OF THE PRICE... 2 ITALIAN SUBS, MINI HAM N CHEESE, 3 DRINKS COSTED 34.00.... HIGHWAY ROBBERY!!! INSANE! WONT BE ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
DC
Dan Carroll
google
06.17.2016
4/5

I love trying mom and pop type places. This place will not disappoint. Their sandwiches are good and they serve breakfast. It is located on broadway in Pitman. It's a perfect place to grab a bite and then go shop or catch a show at the theater.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
DC
Dominick Cella
google
05.22.2016
5/5

Another small business in Pitman, great hoagies, breakfast is good too. The owner is a good guy too, hooked my girlfriend up and I up with some free bread.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
SM
Simmo Mantua
google
05.16.2016
5/5

I tried the Hoagie places in the whole area here around Mantua Mama Marie's is the best Dominic makes the best hoagies I recommend the Little Nicky or the dinghy blue....... fantastic.... you will not be let down with the taste

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JK
Jason Kinner
google
05.05.2016
5/5

Fantastic food at very reasonable prices. Never a bad meal here. Definitely the best hoagies around. The diablo hoagies are very spicy but absolutely delicious. The dingy blue is one of my personal favorites! They also make great party platters here.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JH
Jeffrey Hiatt
google
04.27.2016
5/5

Awesome. Love this place.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
jc
joe cianela
google
04.27.2016
5/5

Great Italian hoagie. Cozy deli with great variety.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
JR
Jon Ruiz
google
03.04.2016
5/5

The best roasted pork sandwich in South Jersey.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
TM
Thomas Mason
google
02.27.2016
4/5

Outstanding ! Great food.

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
AL
Amanda Lasecki
google
02.17.2016
4/5

Their breakfast sandwiches are so good! But it's definitely been hit-or-miss with the service. I was honestly never going to go back after my first encounter with an incredibly rude person that *berated* me for picking up an order my office placed through GrubHub. The order wasn't even ready when I got there, and it was past when it was estimated. But I went in a few weeks later, and both of the people I spoke with were very nice and helpful. So, definitely get breakfast...just don't try to have it delivered!

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
AM
Alyssa Marie Gillon
google
02.06.2016
5/5

Nice sandwich! Thanks guys 💕

Mama Marie`s Italian Market
SA
Steven A Bastow
google
01.14.2016
5/5

Always great food here!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 18565894440

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!